Every time an Agoda customer checks out of a hotel we send them an email asking them to write a review of their stay. This is the only way reviews can be submitted. Every review must then be approved by our content team before being posted on the Agoda website. Therefore, unlike many other travel sites, ALL Agoda reviews are certified and genuine.
Enter your dates to check availability and book this hotel

Hotel Mela Times Square

120 West 44th Street, Times Square, New York (NY), United States 10036

Recent customer reviews

Filter by traveler type

 

Very good

7.9

based on 283 reviews

210 reviews in English

Value for Money
7.6
Location
9.4
Staff Performance
7.8
Hotel Condition/Cleanliness
8.3
Room Comfort/Standard
7.7
Food/Dining
6.5
All reviews (283)
Sort by:
Rebecca G. Couples Australia, April 28, 2016
Great stay
6.7
Good location, clean, modern room, serviced daily. Lovely staff. We have really enjoyed our 8 nights here in NYC. 5 stars all around.
Report this review
Jillian C. Couples United Kingdom, April 1, 2016
Ideal for sightseeing
5.7
Ideal location, staff are extremely pleasant and helpful.room was a little snug, but beautifully clean and you don't spend much time there. Bistro next door is excellent
Report this review
Danielle B. Solo travelers United Kingdom, March 31, 2016
4* Hotel????
5.3
A very average hotel, the worst my husband has stayed in on his several trips to NY in the last few years. The staff were average, no acknowledgement when he walked in and no offer of help with luggage. He requested to move rooms as the first was tiny, dark and looked onto a brick wall. The second was tiny. The hotel looked tired and is in need of a facelift. Good points...Cleanliness was fine and the check out time was ok. You'd be best spending a little extra and staying at the millennium which is over the road or even better the intercontinental.
Report this review
Deborah D. Solo travelers United States of America, March 8, 2016
very nice room for the money.

Pricing,very friendly staff, proximity to shows
9.7
Report this review
Lius D. Couples Indonesia, March 4, 2016
Very near to Times Square

Location location location
7.3
The location is superb but room size is too small
Report this review
Yasir H. Business travelers United States of America, February 19, 2016
costly

there was no toilet brush holder & wash basin chock the water.
8.7
it was good but costly, no chair in the room.
Report this review
Hongying Z. Couples China, January 29, 2016
Good location, convenient for shopping, sightseein
6
The staff is friendly and professional, but some room are very small, our room is upgraded as required.
Report this review
Ashish R. Solo travelers India, December 31, 2015
True value for money because of the Location

Location, Staff and Service, Cleanliness
7.3
I just had a one night stay but it was worth it, it is just 3-4 mins walk from times square and many other touristic spots. Rooms a bit smaller but still ok for a short stay as you might be spending most of the time outside rather than staying in. Overall, I would visit this again just because of the location, friendly and helpful staff and the cleanliness. Worth the money spent
Report this review
Ahmad H. Couples Egypt, November 19, 2015
good hotel but small room

front office manger Mrs Melenad
6.3
not so good as the room very small
Report this review
Isadora B. Solo travelers Indonesia, October 26, 2015
Nice location

Nice and helpful staff, nice location, clean room
8.7
First time staying at hotel mela, like the helpful staff, and the location just nice, will visit again next time!
Report this review
1 - 10 of 210 reviews Next page
Hotel Mela Times Square New York (NY)Hotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Guest RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - RestaurantHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Suite RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Guest RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - InteriorHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - BathroomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Guest RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Guest RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Guest RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Fitness RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Business CenterHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - RestaurantHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Nearby AttractionHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Guest RoomHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - RestaurantHotel Mela Times Square New York (NY) - Food and Beverages


Agoda is part of The Priceline Group, the world leader in online travel & related services.

AS-AGWEB-3C04