Back to hotel info

Verified traveler reviews

Filter by traveler type
Very good

based on 81 reviews
  • Cleanliness 8.1
  • Facilities 8.0
  • Location 9.3
  • Room Comfort/Standard 8.2
  • Service 8.2
  • Value for money 8.0
  • Food/Dining 5.8
Sort by

NAKANO M. from Japan
Solo travelers
Stayed one night in November 2014
Good Atmospher
Atmosphere, Location, Staff
It is a classical hotel and the atmosphere is family-like and good. Though the building is old and facilities in a room are not new, there is no problem for staying. The location is very good and within a walking distance from the Grand central Station and the Fifth Avenue. The staffs are senior people and very reliable. The complementary Greek yoghurt in the lobby lounge is very fine!
Reviewed November 26, 2014

jeffrey P. from United States
Business travelers
Stayed 3 nights in November 2014
location, location, funkyness
Very good
Reviewed November 18, 2014

Art S. from United States
Business travelers
Stayed 2 nights in October 2014
Great Location - Great Value
Location, Location, Location - and Yogurt
The location was great. Right in the middle of everything. It was a simple small NY hotel that was clean with a friendly staff. They also had a small fridge in the lobby with free Greek yogurt and granola which was the perfect quick healthy snack coming in off of a long flight and a great easy breakfast to start the day.
Reviewed October 23, 2014

Michelle W. from United States
Stayed 3 nights in August 2014
Excellent non-chain experience!
Location, comfort (A/C and beds), value
The Roger Smith has a ton of character, but backs it up with all the comforts and amenities that a traveler could want. We absolutely loved it.
Reviewed September 07, 2014

Jeong L. from Hong Kong
Stayed 4 nights in July 2014
very convenient
free greek yoghurt, great location, close to cafes and supermarket
We had an enjoyable stay there. Liked the unique decoration and the elevator in vintage style.
Reviewed July 28, 2014

Jeong L. from Hong Kong
Stayed one night in July 2014
excellent location
location, decoration, free greek yoghurt
The stay was great. Free greek yoghurt and apples every day was a surprise. Just that the beds were too small for a two double queen-sized bed room designed for three people. The bed was slanted when once my friend sank into the bed. Other than that, the hotel was great!
Reviewed July 27, 2014

Alicja P. from Poland
Stayed one night in June 2014
Reviewed July 01, 2014

George R. from United States
Families with young children
Stayed one night in June 2014
Location was awesome!
The location was near to most popular attractions. Easy access to the subway station.Nice restaurants and bars around the area.
Our stay was very convenient, especially the location of the hotel.The price was reasonable and the rooms were comfortable.I would recommend this hotel to my family and friends.
Reviewed June 23, 2014

Alvin L. from Singapore
Business travelers
Stayed 6 nights in June 2014
Enjoyed staying at Roger Smith. Quiet, clean
Location, value for money and the room was quiet and clean. Free Wi,Fi is also appreciated
Room is comfortable and clean though dimly lit. Location is very good. Room was quiet.
Reviewed June 18, 2014

Daniel T. from France
Business travelers
Stayed 6 nights in November 2013
Pretty good
Location, staff, price\quality
Reviewed May 14, 2014