Every time an Agoda customer checks out of a hotel we send them an email asking them to write a review of their stay. This is the only way reviews can be submitted. Every review must then be approved by our content team before being posted on the Agoda website. Therefore, unlike many other travel sites, ALL Agoda reviews are certified and genuine.
Enter your dates to check availability and book this hotel

The Roger Hotel

131 Madison Avenue, Gramercy, New York (NY), United States 10016

Recent customer reviews

Filter by traveler type

 

Excellent

8.4

based on 47 reviews

33 reviews in English

Value for Money
7.8
Location
8.9
Staff Performance
8.5
Hotel Condition/Cleanliness
8.8
Room Comfort/Standard
8.9
Food/Dining
7.7
All reviews (47)
Sort by:
Pawel M. Business travelers United Kingdom, April 9, 2016
Full of extra charges
4
On checking in was told about a $30/day additional 'facility charge' in order to use the gym (I wouldn't pay to use this gym BTW) and internet. This was not made clear at time of booking and frankly, makes the difference between being good value and bordering on expensive. Rooms don't have kettles to force you to buy tea/coffee from the bar and the cheapest bottle of in-room water is over $7!
Report this review
Hee C. Business travelers South Korea, January 22, 2016
Great for the money

Clean room, friendly staff, and modern interior
9.7
nice and comfortable during my stay. strongly recommend!
Report this review
Hee C. Business travelers South Korea, January 22, 2016
Nice clean hotel with friendly staff

spacious room, staff, location
9.3
Liked the spacious room a lot! I've tried many hotels in the city, and was always unhappy with the small room. Very clean and quiet. Great hotel!
Report this review
Hee C. Business travelers South Korea, January 22, 2016
Nice and friendly hotel

nice staff, clean and big room, location
8
satisfied with the room & service quality
Report this review
Anna M. Solo travelers Australia, September 14, 2015
Fabulous hotel

Cool hotel, very clean nice rooms, very helpful staff.
9.3
I had a fabulous stay and would definitely stay again and recommend.
Report this review
David H. Solo travelers United States of America, September 5, 2015
Great Stay!

Service, location, and value
9.3
Friendly and courteous staff- had long flight in and I felt comfortable and right at home. Would stay there again!
Report this review
Helene D. Couples United States of America, June 20, 2015
Wonderful Stay

Clean comfy room, hotel atmosphere, friendly staff
9.7
Everything was wonderful.
Report this review
Elizabeth M. Families with older children United States of America, April 4, 2015
Great location, stylish, comfortable hotel

location, lobby decor, service
9.7
Report this review
Errol C. Business travelers Australia, November 16, 2014
Clean and comfortable

Great staff and clean rooms
7.7
Report this review
Paul B. Couples United States of America, July 21, 2014
Clean, very courteous & friendly staff.

Customer service Courteousness of staff Cleanliness & decor
9
I'd highly recommend this hotel for anyone. Rooms were spacious for New York and very well maintained. The entire staff was attentive & friendly.
Report this review
1 - 10 of 33 reviews Next page
The Roger Hotel New York (NY)The Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - BuffetThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - LobbyThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - ExteriorThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - InteriorThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - LobbyThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - FacilitiesThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - RestaurantThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - SurroundingsThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - LobbyThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - BathroomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Fitness RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - InteriorThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Guest RoomThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - RestaurantThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - TerraceThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - RestaurantThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - Balcony/TerraceThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - SurroundingsThe Roger Hotel New York (NY) - View


Agoda is part of The Priceline Group, the world leader in online travel & related services.

AS-AGWEB-3C05