Amara Cay Resort

4 stars out of 5
80001 Overseas Highway, Upper Matecumbe Key, Islamorada (FL), United States, 33036 - See map

Conveniently situated in the Upper Matecumbe Key part of Islamorada (FL), this property puts you close to attractions and interesting dining options. Rated with 4 stars, this high-quality property provides guests with access to restaurant, fitness center and outdoor pool on-site.

Highlights

Check-in [24-hour]

Daily housekeeping

Bar

Poolside bar

Fitness center

Facilities

Front desk [24-hour]

Bicycle rental

Pets allowed

Car park

Swimming pool [outdoor]

Fitness center

Shuttle service

Check-in/out [express]

Based on 930 verified reviews

Location

8.8

Service

8.7

Cleanliness

8.5

Facilities

8.4

Value for money

7.7

See map

8.8Excellent

Location rating score

Excellent location
Parking
Available
Closest landmarks
Island Trendz Boutique
40 m
Bud n' Mary's Dive Center
370 m
D-Luxe Boutique
1.4 km
The Banyan Tree
1.8 km
Green Turtle Wine and Spirits
1.9 km
Value for money7.7
Location rating8.8

Rooms available at Amara Cay Resort

One-Bedroom Suite
...
  • Room size: 83 m²/893 ft²
  • Sea view
  • 2 queen beds or 1 sofa bed ...
Enter dates to see prices
Partial Ocean View Two Queen Beds
...
  • Room size: 35 m²/377 ft²
  • Sea view
  • 2 queen beds or 2 double be...
Enter dates to see prices
Suite with Sea View
...
  • Room size: 60 m²/646 ft²
  • Sea view
Enter dates to see prices
Oceanfront Suite with Two Queen Beds
...
  • Room size: 58 m²/624 ft²
  • Sea view
  • 2 queen beds or 1 sofa bed ...
Enter dates to see prices
Oceanfront King Room
...
  • Room size: 35 m²/377 ft²
  • Sea view
  • 1 king bed & 1 king bed and...
Enter dates to see prices
Suite Ocean Front One Bedroom
...
  • Non-smoking
Enter dates to see prices
Queen Room with Two Queen Beds
...
  • Room size: 33 m²/355 ft²
  • Balcony/terrace
  • 2 queen beds or 2 double be...
Enter dates to see prices
King Room - Disability Access
...
  • Room size: 31 m²/334 ft²
  • Balcony/terrace
  • 1 king bed or 1 double bed ...
Enter dates to see prices
Oceanfront King Room - Disability Access
...
  • Room size: 35 m²/377 ft²
  • Sea view
  • 1 double bed or 1 king bed ...
Enter dates to see prices
King Room with Sea View
...
  • Room size: 35 m²/377 ft²
  • Sea view
Enter dates to see prices

Frequently asked questions

Does Amara Cay Resort have bars on the premises?

Experience your vacation the best way yet with Amara Cay Resort's bar and poolside bar available right in front of your doorstep for whenever you need a drink or two.

Does Amara Cay Resort have a swimming pool?

While staying at Amara Cay Resort, you can take pleasure in the swimming pool facility to get your day started the best way with a splash for a stimulating morning or evening.

Does Amara Cay Resort have a fitness center?

Amara Cay Resort offers free 24-hour fitness center that is effortlessly located at the tip of your finger, allowing you to get your daily exercise routine in at any time of the day so you can spend your holiday break the way you want. For more details, please contact the property for more information.

What are the property's policies for children's bedding at Amara Cay Resort?

Amara Cay Resort's policy pertaining to children's bedding considers guests age 13 years and older as adults, and therefore must use an extra bed which will incur an additional fee. You can find additional information about specific child policy and age range for this property, by checking the "Property policies" section located in the property page for more details.

How many rooms does Amara Cay Resort have?

Amara Cay Resort has a total of 110 rooms.

How long do visitors normally stay at Amara Cay Resort?

Verified past guests that have stayed at Amara Cay Resort had an average nightly stay of 2 nights at this property.

What was the average room rate for Amara Cay Resort been in the past month?

The typical room rate for Amara Cay Resort in the past month is 277.14 USD, compared to city's average of 206.6 USD.

What payment options are supported at Amara Cay Resort?

Amara Cay Resort supports up to 4, with payment card options including Visa, American Express, and Discover Card.

What do guests like most about Amara Cay Resort?

Verified guests that stayed at Amara Cay Resort have given this property a rating of 8.805 for its remarkable location as the primary highlight for their stay.

What is the average rating that past Business travelers' have given to Amara Cay Resort?

Verified business travelers that have stayed at this property have given Amara Cay Resort an average rating of 7.9. You can look up more detailed customer reviews and remarks by filtering for a specific type of verified travelers down in the review section.

What do local travelers think about Amara Cay Resort?

Verified local travelers that have stayed at this property have given Amara Cay Resort an average rating of 8.3. You can look up on more descriptive customer ratings, and responses for this property down in the review section.

More about Amara Cay Resort

More about Amara Cay Resort

Experience Paradise at Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada

Welcome to Amara Cay Resort, a stunning 4-star hotel nestled in the heart of Islamorada, Florida. With its breathtaking ocean views, luxurious accommodations, and top-notch amenities, this resort is the perfect destination for those seeking a truly unforgettable vacation. As you step into the lobby of Amara Cay Resort, you'll immediately feel a sense of tranquility and relaxation wash over you. The resort boasts 110 beautifully appointed rooms, each designed with comfort and style in mind. Whether you choose a cozy guest room or a spacious suite, you'll find yourself surrounded by modern amenities and elegant furnishings. Check-in at Amara Cay Resort is available from 4:00 PM, allowing you plenty of time to settle in and start enjoying your vacation. The friendly and attentive staff will be there to greet you with warm smiles and ensure that your check-in process is seamless and hassle-free. And with a check-out time of 11:00 AM, you'll have plenty of time to savor your last moments in paradise before bidding farewell to this enchanting resort. Families will be delighted to know that Amara Cay Resort welcomes children between the ages of 3 to 12 to stay free of charge. This child-friendly policy makes it the perfect choice for a family getaway, where both parents and children can create lasting memories together. From the moment you arrive, you'll find a wide range of activities and amenities designed to keep the little ones entertained, from a sparkling swimming pool to a dedicated kids' club. At Amara Cay Resort, every detail has been carefully considered to ensure your stay is nothing short of extraordinary. So why wait? Book your stay at Amara Cay Resort today and experience the ultimate beachfront retreat in Islamorada, Florida.

Endless Entertainment at Amara Cay Resort

At Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada, Florida, you'll find a plethora of entertainment facilities that will keep you entertained throughout your stay. Whether you're in the mood for shopping, unwinding at a vibrant bar, or mingling with other guests in the shared lounge/TV area, this resort has it all. Indulge in a retail therapy session at the onsite shops, where you can browse through a variety of unique items and souvenirs. From trendy beachwear to local artwork, there's something for everyone. After a day of exploring the beautiful surroundings, head to the bar and sip on expertly crafted cocktails while enjoying live music or DJ performances. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff will make you feel right at home. For a more relaxed evening, gather with fellow travelers in the shared lounge/TV area. Catch up on your favorite shows or engage in a friendly game of pool while swapping travel stories with new friends. Whether you're seeking excitement or a cozy night in, Amara Cay Resort offers entertainment facilities that cater to all preferences.

Stay Active and Energized at Amara Cay Resort's Sports Facilities

At Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada, Florida, staying active and energized is a breeze with a wide range of sports facilities available for guests. Whether you're a fitness enthusiast or simply looking to unwind, the resort has something for everyone. Start your day with a refreshing dip in the outdoor pool, surrounded by lush tropical gardens. Lounge by the poolside bar, sipping on a refreshing cocktail while soaking up the sun. If you prefer the sand between your toes, head to the pristine beach just steps away from the resort. Bask in the warm Florida sun, build sandcastles, or take a leisurely stroll along the shoreline. For those who like to maintain their fitness routine while on vacation, Amara Cay Resort offers a free 24-hour fitness center. Equipped with state-of-the-art equipment, you can break a sweat and stay in shape at any time of the day. Whether you prefer cardio exercises or strength training, the fitness center has everything you need to keep up with your fitness goals. With its impressive array of sports facilities, Amara Cay Resort ensures that guests can stay active and energized throughout their stay. So, whether you're looking to relax by the pool, enjoy a drink at the poolside bar, soak up the sun on the beach, or work out at the fitness center, this resort has it all.

Convenience Facilities at Amara Cay Resort: Enhancing Your Stay in Islamorada

Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada, Florida, offers an array of convenience facilities to ensure a comfortable and hassle-free stay for all guests. With room service available, you can indulge in delicious meals and refreshing beverages without leaving the comfort of your room. Whether you're craving a hearty breakfast or a late-night snack, the friendly staff at Amara Cay Resort is ready to cater to your culinary desires. Stay connected throughout your stay with complimentary Wi-Fi in public areas. Whether you need to catch up on work emails, stream your favorite shows, or share your vacation photos on social media, you can do it all effortlessly at Amara Cay Resort. The seamless connectivity ensures that you can stay connected with loved ones and stay updated on the latest happenings. For guests who prefer to smoke, Amara Cay Resort offers a designated smoking area where you can enjoy your cigarette in a comfortable and socially responsible environment. This designated area ensures that non-smoking guests can enjoy a smoke-free atmosphere throughout the rest of the resort. Experience the convenience of daily housekeeping services at Amara Cay Resort. The dedicated housekeeping team ensures that your room is always clean and tidy, allowing you to relax and unwind without worrying about the daily chores. Additionally, the resort also provides a laundromat facility, making it easy for guests to keep their clothes fresh and clean during their stay. With these exceptional convenience facilities, Amara Cay Resort goes above and beyond to enhance your stay in Islamorada. Whether you're here for business or leisure, you can enjoy a seamless and stress-free experience at this charming resort.

Convenient and Hassle-Free Transport Facilities at Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada, Florida, offers a range of transport facilities to ensure a convenient and hassle-free stay for its guests. The resort features an onsite car park, allowing guests to easily park their vehicles upon arrival. With self-parking available, guests can have peace of mind knowing their cars are secure and accessible throughout their stay. What's more, the car park is free of charge, providing an additional benefit for those traveling with their own vehicles. For guests who prefer not to drive, Amara Cay Resort also offers a convenient shuttle service. This service allows guests to explore the surrounding area without the worry of navigating unfamiliar roads or finding parking. Whether it's visiting the nearby attractions, dining at local restaurants, or simply exploring the beautiful Islamorada, the shuttle service provides a hassle-free transportation option. With these transport facilities, Amara Cay Resort ensures that guests can easily get around and make the most of their stay in this stunning part of Florida.





Indulge in Culinary Delights at Amara Cay Resort

At Amara Cay Resort, dining is an experience to remember. With a range of dining facilities available, including a coffee shop, restaurant, and room service, guests are spoiled for choice when it comes to satisfying their culinary cravings. Start your day off right at the resort's coffee shop, where you can enjoy a freshly brewed cup of coffee and a selection of pastries. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot to relax and plan your day ahead. For a more formal dining experience, head to the resort's restaurant, where you can indulge in a delectable array of dishes. From fresh seafood to mouthwatering steaks, the menu offers something to please every palate. The restaurant's elegant ambiance and attentive service create the perfect setting for a romantic dinner or a memorable celebration. If you prefer to dine in the comfort of your own room, take advantage of the convenient room service option. Whether you're craving a late-night snack or a full meal, the menu offers a variety of options to satisfy your hunger. To ensure your stay is as comfortable as possible, daily housekeeping is provided, ensuring that your dining area is always clean and inviting. At Amara Cay Resort, dining is not just a necessity, but a delightful experience that adds to the overall enjoyment of your stay.

Luxurious and Spacious Rooms at Amara Cay Resort

Experience ultimate comfort and relaxation in the beautifully appointed rooms at Amara Cay Resort. Choose from a variety of room types to suit your preferences and needs. The 1 Bedroom King Suite offers a plush king bed for a restful night's sleep, while the 1 Bedroom Oceanfront King Suite provides stunning views of the ocean. For larger groups, the 1 Bedroom Suite 2 Queen Beds and 1 Bedroom Suite, 2 Queen are perfect with their spacious layout and two queen beds. Whether you prefer a courtyard view or an oceanfront oasis, Amara Cay Resort has a room option for everyone. By booking your stay at Amara Cay Resort through Agoda, you can enjoy the best prices and a hassle-free experience. Agoda guarantees the lowest rates on all room types, ensuring that you get the best value for your money. With Agoda's user-friendly platform, you can easily browse and compare different room options, making it convenient to find the perfect accommodation for your stay. So why wait? Book your dream getaway at Amara Cay Resort on Agoda today and enjoy a seamless booking process and unbeatable prices.

Discover the Charm of Upper Matecumbe Key in Islamorada

Nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, Upper Matecumbe Key is a tropical paradise that offers a unique blend of natural beauty, rich history, and vibrant culture. This enchanting island is part of the picturesque village of Islamorada, known as the 'Sportfishing Capital of the World.' With its pristine white sandy beaches, crystal-clear turquoise waters, and breathtaking sunsets, Upper Matecumbe Key is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts and beach lovers alike. Spend your days lounging on the beach, snorkeling in the vibrant coral reefs, or indulging in exciting water sports such as kayaking, paddleboarding, and jet skiing. Beyond its natural wonders, Upper Matecumbe Key is also home to a variety of charming shops, art galleries, and delectable dining options. Explore the vibrant local art scene, browse unique boutiques, and savor fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants. For history buffs, a visit to the History of Diving Museum is a must, showcasing the fascinating evolution of diving equipment and techniques. Whether you're seeking relaxation or adventure, Upper Matecumbe Key has something for everyone. Immerse yourself in the laid-back island lifestyle, soak up the sun, and create unforgettable memories in this tropical paradise.

Traveling to Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada

Welcome to Amara Cay Resort, a tropical paradise nestled in the heart of Islamorada, Florida. Getting to this stunning resort is a breeze, thanks to its convenient location near several airports. If you're flying into the area, the closest airport to Amara Cay Resort is the Key West International Airport, located approximately 75 miles south of Islamorada. From the airport, you can rent a car or take a taxi to reach the resort. The scenic drive along the Overseas Highway will take you through the beautiful Florida Keys, offering breathtaking views of the turquoise waters and lush landscapes. Another option is to fly into the Miami International Airport, which is about 80 miles north of Islamorada. From there, you can rent a car or take a shuttle service to reach Amara Cay Resort. The drive from Miami to Islamorada is equally picturesque, as you pass by stunning coastal views and charming seaside towns. Once you arrive at Amara Cay Resort, you'll be greeted by a serene and luxurious atmosphere. The resort offers a range of amenities, including a private beach, a pool, and a spa, ensuring that you have everything you need for a relaxing and memorable stay. Whether you're looking to unwind by the pool, explore the nearby coral reefs, or indulge in delicious seafood at the resort's restaurant, Amara Cay Resort is the perfect destination for your tropical getaway.

Discover the Hidden Gems near Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada

Nestled in the heart of Islamorada, Amara Cay Resort offers a tranquil oasis surrounded by a plethora of captivating landmarks and attractions. Just a short distance away, you'll find the historic Matecumbe United Methodist Church, a charming landmark that showcases the rich cultural heritage of the area. Take a leisurely stroll through its picturesque grounds and admire the beautiful architecture that dates back to the early 1900s. For those seeking relaxation and rejuvenation, a visit to the Island Body & Sol Spa is a must. Indulge in a variety of luxurious treatments, from soothing massages to invigorating facials, all designed to pamper your senses and restore your inner balance. Immerse yourself in a world of tranquility as skilled therapists work their magic, leaving you feeling refreshed and revitalized. If you're a history enthusiast, the nearby History of Diving Museum is a fascinating attraction that offers a unique glimpse into the evolution of underwater exploration. Discover the captivating stories of legendary divers and explore a vast collection of artifacts, including vintage diving equipment and rare photographs. Dive into the rich history of the sport and gain a deeper appreciation for the pioneers who paved the way for modern-day diving. For adventure seekers, Bud n' Mary's Dive Center is the ultimate destination. Embark on thrilling diving and snorkeling excursions, where you'll have the opportunity to explore the vibrant coral reefs and encounter an array of marine life. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced diver, the knowledgeable staff will ensure a safe and memorable underwater experience. As you explore the area, don't miss the Hurricane Monument, a powerful reminder of the devastating impact of past hurricanes. This iconic landmark stands as a testament to the resilience and strength of the local community, serving as a poignant reminder of the challenges they have overcome. With its prime location amidst these captivating landmarks and attractions, Amara Cay Resort offers the perfect base for an unforgettable vacation. Immerse yourself in the rich history, natural beauty, and adventurous spirit of Islamorada, and create memories that will last a lifetime.





Delicious Dining Options Near Amara Cay Resort

When it comes to dining near Amara Cay Resort, guests are spoilt for choice. Just a short stroll away, Bumby's Raw Bar and Local Libations is a must-visit for seafood lovers. Indulge in fresh oysters, mouthwatering shrimp, and other delectable seafood dishes while enjoying the laid-back atmosphere. For a quick and convenient bite, Subway is located just around the corner, offering a variety of sandwiches and salads. Craving a hearty breakfast? Look no further than Mangrove Mike's Cafe, where you can savor delicious omelets, pancakes, and French toast. Kev's Cafe is another great option for breakfast or lunch, serving up hearty American classics like burgers, sandwiches, and wraps. For a taste of local flavor, head to Ma's Fish Camp, where you can feast on freshly caught seafood and enjoy stunning waterfront views. If you prefer to cook your own meals, Trading Post Grocery Store is conveniently located nearby, offering a wide selection of groceries and supplies. For an authentic Italian dining experience, Limoncello is a popular choice, serving up mouthwatering pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, and homemade gelato. Seafood lovers can also delight in the fresh catch at Islamorada Fish Company, a waterfront restaurant offering a diverse menu of seafood specialties. Whale Harbor Inn is another fantastic option for seafood enthusiasts, offering an extensive menu of fresh seafood dishes and waterfront dining. And for those looking for a lively atmosphere, The Whistle Stop Bar & Grill is the perfect spot to enjoy delicious pub fare, refreshing drinks, and live music. With such a diverse range of dining options just steps away from the resort, guests at Amara Cay Resort can truly indulge in a culinary adventure during their stay.

Shop 'til You Drop

Amara Cay Resort is surrounded by an array of shopping landmarks that will delight even the most discerning shoppers. Just steps away from the hotel, guests can explore The Banyan Tree, a charming boutique offering unique clothing, accessories, and home decor. Island Trendz Boutique is another must-visit destination, featuring a curated collection of beachwear and resort attire. For those seeking the latest fashion trends, Zero Dress Code Boutique is the go-to spot, offering a wide selection of stylish clothing and accessories. Art enthusiasts will be captivated by the Lobster Trap Art Gallery and Stacie Krupa Studio Gallery of Art, showcasing stunning works by local artists. Ocean Gardens is a haven for plant lovers, offering a variety of beautiful plants and gardening essentials. Bookworms will find their paradise at Hooked on Books, a cozy bookstore with an extensive collection of novels and bestsellers. For unique souvenirs and gifts, Islamorada Mercantile is a treasure trove of locally made crafts and artisanal products. In Limbo is a boutique that specializes in bohemian-inspired clothing and accessories, perfect for those looking to embrace a laid-back island style. And to top it all off, Green Turtle Wine and Spirits is the ideal spot to stock up on fine wines, craft beers, and spirits. With these shopping landmarks just a stone's throw away, guests at Amara Cay Resort can indulge in a delightful retail therapy experience during their stay.

Affordable Luxury: Experience Amara Cay Resort at a Great Value

When it comes to finding the perfect blend of luxury and affordability in Islamorada (FL), look no further than Amara Cay Resort. With an average room price of just $305, this stunning beachfront retreat offers exceptional value for money. Compared to the average price of a hotel room in the city, which stands at $272, Amara Cay Resort provides a truly remarkable experience without breaking the bank. At Amara Cay Resort, you'll be treated to a wide range of amenities and services that are sure to exceed your expectations. From the moment you step foot into the beautifully designed lobby, you'll be greeted by friendly staff who are committed to ensuring your stay is nothing short of extraordinary. The elegantly appointed rooms feature modern furnishings, plush bedding, and breathtaking views of the ocean or the resort's lush gardens. Whether you're lounging by the pool, indulging in a rejuvenating spa treatment, or savoring delicious cuisine at the on-site restaurant, every moment at Amara Cay Resort is designed to provide you with an unforgettable experience. With its unbeatable combination of luxury, convenience, and affordability, Amara Cay Resort is the ideal choice for travelers who want to make the most of their stay in Islamorada (FL). Don't miss out on the opportunity to experience this hidden gem at a great value. Book your stay at Amara Cay Resort today and prepare to be captivated by its charm and elegance.

Exceptional Staff and Beautiful Amenities

Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada (FL) is highly praised by its guests for its exceptional staff and beautiful amenities. The friendly and professional staff at the front desk goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay, providing helpful assistance and making guests feel welcome. The hotel boasts a stunning pool, which is described as beautiful and clean, offering a refreshing oasis for relaxation. The rooms are spacious and well-maintained, with cleanliness being a top priority. Overall, Amara Cay Resort is a fantastic choice for those seeking a friendly and comfortable stay with outstanding amenities.

A Tropical Paradise with Exceptional Customer Ratings

Welcome to Amara Cay Resort, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Islamorada, Florida. With an impressive overall rating of 8.6, this resort has garnered positive feedback from countless satisfied guests. From the moment you step foot on the property, you'll be captivated by the stunning tropical surroundings and the warm, friendly atmosphere that permeates every aspect of your stay. One of the standout features of Amara Cay Resort is its exceptional staff performance, which has been rated at an impressive 9.0. The dedicated team goes above and beyond to ensure that every guest feels welcomed and well taken care of. Whether you need assistance with arranging activities, recommendations for local attractions, or simply a friendly chat, the staff at Amara Cay Resort is always ready to help with a genuine smile. Another aspect that sets this resort apart is its unbeatable location, earning a remarkable rating of 9.0. Situated right on the beach, guests can enjoy breathtaking views of the turquoise waters and feel the gentle ocean breeze. With easy access to a range of water sports activities and world-class fishing spots, adventure awaits just steps away from your room. Additionally, the resort is conveniently located near popular attractions, charming boutiques, and delectable dining options, ensuring that you have everything you need at your fingertips.

Show less

Amenities and facilities

Excellent8.4

Facilities

Languages spoken
  • English
  • Spanish
Outdoor
  • Bicycles
Accessibility
  • On-site accessible restaurants / lounges
  • Wheelchair accessible
Internet access
  • Free Wi-Fi in all rooms!
  • Internet
  • Internet services
  • Wi-Fi in public areas
Things to do, ways to relax
  • Diving
  • Fishing
  • Fitness center
  • Garden
  • On-site entertainment
  • Pool with view
  • Private beach
  • Snorkeling
  • Swimming pool [outdoor]
  • Water sports (non-motorized)
Cleanliness and safety
  • Anti-viral cleaning products
  • Breakfast takeaway service
  • Cashless payment service
  • First aid kit
  • Hand sanitizer
  • Hot water linen and laundry washing
  • Individually-wrapped food options
  • Room sanitization opt-out available
  • Safe dining setup
  • Sanitized kitchen and tableware items
  • Staff trained in safety protocol
Dining, drinking, and snacking
  • A la carte breakfast
  • Alcohol
  • Alternative meal arrangement
  • Bar
  • Breakfast service
  • Coffee shop
  • Poolside bar
  • Restaurants
  • Room service
  • Snack bar
Services and conveniences
  • Air conditioning in public area
  • Concierge
  • Contactless check-in/out
  • Convenience store
  • Daily housekeeping
  • Elevator
  • Facilities for disabled guests
  • Laundromat
  • Laundry service
  • Luggage storage
  • Meeting/banquet facilities
  • Shared lounge/TV area
  • Shops
  • Smoking area
  • Terrace
For the kids
  • Family room
  • Kids meal
Land sports
  • Golf course (within 3 km)
Access
  • CCTV in common areas
  • Check-in/out [express]
  • Check-in [24-hour]
  • Dog-friendly
  • Front desk [24-hour]
  • Non-smoking rooms
  • Pet-friendly [charges apply]
  • Pets allowed
  • Pets may not be left unattended
  • Proposal spot
  • Safety/security feature
  • Service animals are welcome
  • Smoke alarms
Getting around
  • Car park [charges apply]
  • Car park [on-site]
  • Car power charging station
  • Shuttle service
Sports equipment rental
  • Bicycle rental

Food and dining

Restaurants on site
ReelCatch
  • Cuisine: American
  • Menu: A-la-carte

Location

80001 Overseas Highway, Upper Matecumbe Key, Islamorada (FL), United States, 33036

Excellent8.8

Location

Property policies

Children and extra beds

Extra beds are dependent on the room you choose. Please check the individual room capacity for more details.

All children are welcome.

Infant 0-2 year(s)
Stay for free if using existing bedding.
Baby cot/crib may be requested directly from the property.
Children 3-12 year(s)
Must use an extra bed
If you need an extra bed, it will incur an additional charge.
Guests 13 years and older are considered as adults
Must use an extra bed which will incur an additional charge.
Others
  • Wi-Fi/Internet access is available at the property at an additional charge, included in the daily resort fee.
  • Resort fee inclusions: Access to three resorts in the Islamorada Resort Collection; fitness centers; bicycles, kayak, and paddleboard rentals; lawn games; shuttle service; daily resort events and activities; beach and pool chaise lounges and umbrellas; in-room coffee; one reusable PATH™ water bottle per guest, per stay; Wi-Fi; local and toll-free phone calls; and parking
  • When booking more than 5 rooms, different policies and additional supplements may apply.

Some helpful facts

Check-in/Check-out
  • Check-in from16:00
  • Check-out until11:00
Extras
  • Daily Internet/Wi-Fi fee0 USD
The property
  • Number of rooms 110

Property announcements

To reserve your accommodations, Amara Cay Resort requires a deposit of one-night room, tax, and the daily resort fee at the time of booking, with the exception of advance purchase reservations. Upon arrival, your credit card will be authorized for the remaining of your room reservation, tax, and resort fee, and authorized $100 per night for incidentals. Any unused funds will be released at the time of checkout. It may take 3-5 business days for the refund to reflect on your bank account.The Shuttle service hours to 7:00 a.m. - 11:00 p.m. daily

In-room dining working hours:
Breakfast: 07:00 to 11:00 Daily
Lunch and Dinner: 11:30 to 23:00 Daily

The guest laundry at Amara Cay is complimentary and soaps are available for purchase.

Reviews of Amara Cay Resort from real guests

Provided by verified guests of

Agoda logo
8.4

Excellent

Recent ratings trend

10 most recent verified ratings received by the property

  • 9.6
  • 10
  • 9.2
  • 10
  • 7.2
  • 4.4
  • 8.4
  • 6.4
  • 7.6
  • 2.8

Most recent

Location8.8
Service8.7
Cleanliness8.5
Facilities8.4
Value for money7.7
High score for Islamorada (FL)
Rating
9+ Exceptional (16)
8-9 Excellent (5)
7-8 Very Good (3)
6-7 Good (4)
<6 Below Expectation (5)
Guest Type
Language

Show reviews that mention 

Showing 33 verified guest comments
12345
6.4
Good
David from United States
Couple
King Room with Partial Ocean View
Stayed 3 nights in July 2024

They’ve gone downhill”

Asked for early check in. Get there at 12:00pm and they say room is ready but they have to inspect first. They made us wait until 3:00pm Go to pool 2nd day. Return to room at 4:00pm and it still wasn’t cleaned. Then the person cleaning the room went through our stuff…!!! Hotel next door has pool privileges. We go to the pool bar to order food and people not staying at the hotel started moving our stuff so they could take our longe chairs….!!! Very poor security. If I knew others that weren’t staying at the hotel could use the pool, etc…I would have never booked a room.

Reviewed August 03, 2024
9.2
Exceptional
Andrew from Canada
Couple
Room, 1 King Bed, Accessible, Courtyard View (1 King Bed)
Stayed 3 nights in January 2024

Trip to the Keys”

Hotel was clean humid but comfortable. Although having a room facing the courtyard was nice they hotel plays music through the loud speakers and we had to call down at 3:00am asking to turn it off. The music came back on at 7:00am. Our complaint was taken although they claimed that it was “policy”.

Reviewed February 03, 2024
10.0
Exceptional
Shelley from United States
Solo traveler
Stayed 3 nights in May 2021

Clean and spacious!”

The Amaray Cay Hotel was clean and very spacious throughout the resort. Staff was helpful and friendly too. The pool area was full everyday, which is great for families with kids, but not as enjoyable for a solo traveler. I did, however, take full advantage of the ample cabana inspired chill spots on the ocean! There really is enough room and something for everyone to enjoy. All good things aside...I suggest passing on dinning at the hotel. The food wasn't very fresh, so go and enjoy other restaurant in the area! The shuttle will take you any place you want to go. Hope this helps!

Reviewed May 12, 2021
2.8
Mark from United States
Couple
Suite
Stayed 2 nights in August 2024

No service”

Arrived and room was dirty. Bed not made, Food trash. Tried to put us in accessibility room. We refused it’s not what we booked.Would not do anything else for us. Didn’t offer to clean original room. Never said sorry.

Reviewed August 27, 2024
8.4
Excellent
Michael from United Kingdom
Family with young children
One-Bedroom Suite
Stayed 2 nights in July 2024

Great pit stop”

Hotel was very nicely set out and pool and outside sunbeds were great by night looking at the stars and accross the sea

Reviewed July 25, 2024
12345

This is a popular property. Don't miss out!