select your datePlease enter your stay dates to see price
Bay Shore Inn
King Room - Smoking  Bay Shore Inn
Lobby Bay Shore Inn
Lobby Bay Shore Inn
See all 40 photos

Bay Shore Inn

300 Bay Shore Road, West Islip, West Islip, United States, NY 11706 - See map
Free Wi-Fi
See map
Nearby landmarks
Republic Airport 11.8 km
Long Island MacArthur Airport 16.4 km
John F. Kennedy International Airport 43.4 km
LaGuardia Airport 50.5 km
Westchester County Airport 51.9 km
Teterboro Airport 67.7 km
Tweed New Haven Airport 68.1 km
Newark Liberty International Airport 75.8 km
East Hampton Airport 90.3 km
Monmouth Executive Airport 94.1 km
  • Free Wi-Fi in all rooms!

  • Air conditioning

  • Daily housekeeping

  • Vending machine

  • Car park

Value for money6.0
Location rating6.9

Rooms available at Bay Shore Inn

Queen Room with Two Queen Beds - Non Smoking
...
  • Room size: 19 m²/205 ft²
  • Bathtub
  • 2 queen beds
Enter dates to see prices
King Room - Smoking
...
  • Room size: 17 m²/183 ft²
  • Shower and bathtub
  • 1 king bed
Enter dates to see prices
Queen Room with Two Queen Beds - Smoking
...
  • Room size: 19 m²/205 ft²
  • Bathtub
  • 2 queen beds
Enter dates to see prices
King Room - Non-Smoking
...
  • Room size: 17 m²/183 ft²
  • Shower and bathtub
  • 1 king bed
Enter dates to see prices
Queen Room - Disability Access/Non-Smoking
...
  • Room size: 17 m²/183 ft²
  • Bathtub
  • 1 queen bed
Enter dates to see prices
Guest Room (No Window,Area:18)
...
    Enter dates to see prices
    DOUBLE ROOM QUEEN BED FOR NON-SMOKERS
    ...
      Enter dates to see prices
      2 DOBLE BEDS
      ...
        Enter dates to see prices
        Run of House
        ...
          Enter dates to see prices
          DOUBLE BED FOR NON-SMOKERS
          ...
            Enter dates to see prices

            Frequently asked questions

            What time is check-in and check-out at Bay Shore Inn?

            Check-in is from 01:00 PM, and check-out is until 11:00 AM. You may request early check-in or late check-out during booking, subject to availability. Guests checking in or out before or after the designated periods may be charged an additional fee. The front desk is always open, day or night.

            How do I get to Bay Shore Inn?

            For those who wish to drive their own cars, Bay Shore Inn has a car park available for guests. Parking is free for guests.

            See map
            Explore the neighborhood
            Up to 30% off with Agoda Insider Deals!

            Prices drop the moment you sign in!

            Sign in now
            Overall rating:

            6.1

            Good
            155 reviews
            Cleanliness
            5.9
            Facilities
            5.6
            Location
            6.9
            Read all reviews >
            More about Bay Shore Inn

            More about Bay Shore Inn

            This Bay Shore motel offers free Wi-Fi and rooms equipped with cable TV with HBO film channel. The Fire Island Ferry is 4 miles away. Traditionally decorated rooms feature brightly colored walls. Select rooms at Bayshore Inn offer a spa bath. A refrigerator and microwave are available upon request. A 24-hour reception is offered for guests at Long Island’s Bayshore Inn. For shopping, guests can go to Tanger Outlet Mall that is 3 miles away or the Westfield South Shore Mall that is less than 5 minutes’ drive away.

            Show less

            What they offer

            Show less

            Property's guest policies

            Show less

            Some helpful facts

            Show less

            Property announcements

            Show less

            Reviews of Bay Shore Inn from real guests

            Verified reviews provided by Booking
            6.1
            /
            10
            Good
            Cleanliness5.9
            Facilities5.6
            Location6.9
            Room comfort and quality5.9
            Service6.5
            Value for money6.0
            High score for West Islip
            Rating
            9+ Exceptional (10)
            8-9 Excellent (3)
            7-8 Very Good (28)
            6-7 Good (10)
            <6 Below Expectation (85)
            Time of the year
            Mar - May (0)
            Jun - Aug (0)
            Sep - Nov (0)
            Dec - Feb (0)
            All guests (155)
            All languages
            Showing 136 verified guest comments
            12345
            1.0
            Tamika
            Family with young children

            Not worth it”

            The closeness to my expected location was ideal and they had decent parking, otherwise, I was unhappy with the accommodations. There was also places to eat and gas nearby.
            The room barely looked clean, there was a very strong smell in the hallway, and there was only 1 unused plug in the room for a 2 bedroom room. The beds had on sheets with cigarette holes in it and the...
            Reviewed July 22, 2021

            See room deals

            8.0
            Excellent
            Anonymous
            Family with young children

            Very good”

            It was nice n clean
            Reviewed June 30, 2021

            See room deals

            6.0
            Danielle
            Family with young children

            Pleasant”

            That the room was easy to get to for my son with wheel chair
            Not friendly brads felt m like sleeping on cardboard
            Reviewed June 17, 2021

            See room deals

            1.0
            Sofia
            Group

            I would not come back.”

            Staff was rude as hell.
            That the staff was rude.
            Reviewed May 29, 2021

            See room deals

            1.0
            Anonymous
            Couple

            Smells like marijuana throughout the...”

            Nothing
            Everything
            Reviewed March 22, 2021

            See room deals

            1.0
            Amber
            Couple

            Bad”

            Nothing
            When I arrived the lady was very rude and said they dont take reservations and booking should have never reserved me a room. She just kept speaking over me and saying that, not once did she offer me ...
            Reviewed January 01, 2021

            See room deals

            1.0
            Anonymous
            Solo traveler

            Don’t GO HERE ”

            Nothing .
            Worst hotel rude service waste of money and time . Close this place down before I do . Booking should take this trash down . Tired of these unprofessional dirty hotels .
            Reviewed August 11, 2020

            See room deals

            1.0
            John
            Business traveler

            Very dissatisfied”

            Horrible service, the first remove we got had no lock on the door. Broken mirror stinking room dirty towels. Dirty nails on the floor no coffee smelly soap. No shampoo conditioner never again.
            Horrible everything was horrible....
            Reviewed August 08, 2020

            See room deals

            5.0
            Anonymous
            Solo traveler

            Passable”

            It’s a trap spot!!!
            Reviewed July 29, 2020

            See room deals

            6.0
            Anonymous
            Couple

            Never again”

            The maid service was the greatest part of the experience the lady was super nice. Shower and ac worked. I wasn&#39;t really bothered.
            The lady that checked me in was nice just seemed shocked I was there. Most of the other staff were poor with their service and manners. Not great or clean in the room, a large amount of maintenance ...
            Reviewed July 09, 2020

            See room deals

            7.0
            Very good
            Jose
            Family with young children

            Good”

            All was good
            Reviewed July 05, 2020

            See room deals

            7.1
            Very good
            David
            Couple

            Good”

            Everything was to my satisfaction given that I knew this was the cheapest option in the area. You don’t get a Rolls Royce when you pay for a Yugo. Staff was very good.
            This is an aged facility. Looks bad from the street. Corridors look scary. Room was fine.
            Reviewed June 29, 2020

            See room deals

            10.0
            Exceptional
            Julian
            Business traveler

            Exceptional”

            The room was very pleasant. The bed was very comfortably big. The staff was quite nice when assisting.
            Reviewed May 20, 2020

            See room deals

            1.0
            Emily
            Couple

            Worst motel I&#39;ve ever been...”

            Nothing
            Rooms were filthy, staff was rude and careless, wi-Fi sucked, Showers kept cutting in and out from hot to cold, mold in the shower
            Reviewed May 06, 2020

            See room deals

            1.0
            Anonymous
            Business traveler

            Not at all recommendable!!!!!??? Never...”

            A month free at a local hotel or air b nb . Please contact me asap before I call the BBB.
            Charged me an extra 80 50 deposit and 30 every single day ! cas the room they gave me was more upity then the one on line they said . And I asked them is that legal. And then they didn&#39;t answer. ...
            Reviewed March 25, 2020

            See room deals

            8.0
            Excellent
            Diane
            Couple

            Very good”

            Close too stored
            No microwave refrigerate
            Reviewed March 19, 2020

            See room deals

            1.0
            Leonardo
            Couple

            Very dissapointing”

            Place was a flop house. Entire bldg smellednof weed. Dirty dingy walls and bathroom look and was horrible. Never again!
            A toral renovarion and cleaner altogethwr
            Reviewed February 16, 2020

            See room deals

            4.0
            Violet
            Couple

            Disappointing”

            New pillows
            Noise in hallway between 1 and 4am Doors kept slamming Shower go hot and cold while showering Toilet backed up Cigarette smoke smell in hallway TV fuzzy...when asking front desk they said all ...
            Reviewed February 04, 2020

            See room deals

            9.0
            Exceptional
            Paul
            Couple

            Nice hotel for a quick...”

            Old property but well taken care of. Very clean, great central location, close to everything, no amenities, but I was not looking for that. Not the Taj Mahal, but for the price, you shouldn&#39;t ...
            Smoke smell. Was not overbearing, and it disappeared when in the room. Shower door was a little out of joint, but pressure was great. Outside doors leading from parking to rooms are sometimes left ...
            Reviewed January 25, 2020

            See room deals

            7.0
            Very good
            Diane
            Group

            Need more deals like the...”

            Close too store
            HoBreakfast was oldw long you can stay.
            Reviewed January 15, 2020

            See room deals

            12345
            This is a popular property. Don't miss out!

            Back to search results

            Back to room choices

            |

            Dismiss

            null