Extremely pleasant”

We were delighted with our one night stay at the City Club Hotel. Just off Times Square and the price was a bargain. Our room was small but we knew that going in since it was a "petite room". But for just one night, it was perfect and we really wouldn't mind staying there even if were longer. Staff was very courteous and room was clean. Then we had a great bathroom with beautiful large shower plus a bidet!..We were surprised to find two delicious chocolate chip cookies on our turned down bed when we returned in the evening and also had a copy of the NY Times the next morning. We will definitely be staying there again.

City Club Hotel”

Our stay at the City Club Hotel was in two words amazing . I can not think how they could improve on it , it was flawless . I had read that the rooms were small but man are they well thought out , every amenity you could want and never once did we feel cramped .The bathroom was simply wonderful with the best shower I may have ever taken , didn't want to get out . We traveled with our two dogs and every member of the staff was an animal lover and were just so friendly to my dogs! There is a park two blocks away on 42nd st for the dogs to do their bussiness . The location of course is ideal to take in a show and everything from the best New York delis to fine dining options all around you . I know I will never stay at any other hotel in New York if I happen to return there .

Great Service”

We had a very comfortable stay at City Club. Good location, friendly staff, excellent service, very clean rooms and bathrooms. Highly recommended. There is also a coffee shop right across and a diner just beside the hotel. And if you're into the Celebrity Chef scene, Daniel Boulud is just downstairs. I'm definitely booking here again when I return to New York.

It was gorgeous!!!”

We booked the petite room for one night, and since we booked the room in a last minute with much much cheaper price than we've expected, to be honest, we didn't really expect much (Especially because hotel was in such an useful location). But it was just GORGEOUS!! They kept our bags in the morning before we check-in, and when we came back there to properly check-in, they told us that they upgraded our room (without extra charge!). We thought we just get a slight bigger room than the petite room, but it was actually much much bigger room with 2 floors!!!! Everything was clean, amenities were great, bathroom was wonderful, bed was huge and there was a big window!!! Also as I wrote above, location was wonderful where it only takes 5 mins to walk to the main times square area on foot! We wish we could stay there longer than just one night!!! We would definitely stay here again when we will come back to Manhattan again! LOVED IT!

Great place to stay ”

I stayed with City Club just after new years and found it to be a great stay. From the great Bellman to the ladies at the check in, our welcome was nice. Very close to all of the tourist spots as well as food and drinks. I will definitely be staying with then again the next time my family of 6 visit NYC. Thank you City Club!

Friendly Boutique Hotel”

I had a very good experience at City Club Hotel New York. Had a room upgrade when I checked in and I was very happy throughout the stay. Very friendly and accommodating staff. Location is great and convenient to go around New York City from here.

FABULOUS Little Hotel!”

City Club was a big part of our wonderful stay in NY City. So close to all the Broadway Shows, great restaurants & shopping. The staff were very helpful in all aspects & we will definitely be making it our "home" next visit!

Wonderful Stay”

The City Club Hotel is in the perfect location. It was comfortable, the staff was excellent, and I would recommend it to anyone. The price is great for locale and for it being such a nice hotel.

Attentive staff, clean rooms, great location”

Everything you'd expect from a smaller quality New York hotel -- clean rooms, good service and a wonderful touch of color and style ... . You are not in a cookie-cutter shoe box. It is not lavish or enormous, but you are comfortable and feel like you are living in style. Good job.

Exceptional”

We stayed in the deluxe double room for 5 and it was definitely spacious compared to other hotels in that area. The room was clean and loved the nice C. O. Bigelow shower products included daily. Given the number of people per room, you may want to consider bringing bathroom freshener as it doesn't ventilate fast enough. Our room didn't come with a coffee maker and there wasn't any hotel coffee in the lobby/2nd floor sitting area (maybe would be a nice hotel suggestion ;)) so we sent the kid across the street to get morning coffee. Staff is super friendly and we enjoyed our daily cookies. Like other reviewers the location is great. Aside from travel to/from airport, we walked and took public transportation everywhere we needed to go. There was never a need to stay in the hotel since shopping, park, eating was just a few minutes walk away. Would definitely stay here again on our next trip to NYC!

Outstanding Service & Great Location”

City Club Hotel was an extremely positive experience. The hotel offered a great location and the entire staff was outstanding — definitely conquered the lost art of customer service. Thoroughly enjoyed our stay!!!

Complimentary Chocolate Chip COOKIES!!”

Great small hotel walking distance to Times Square and Penn Station. The best part was that we arrived kinda late and were starving for dinner. When we checked in two delicious cookies were waiting for us on our bed! It was perfect to tie us over til dinner. Great place to stay and reasonably priced.

Good location, great staff! ”

Our first time to stay in New York and the location of the hotel was very convenient. We ran into some problem with our airline and the staff really did their best to accommodate us. Look for Alisha, she’s the best!

Hidden Gem”

We spent 3 days in Ciry Club as a family of 6 after nearly weeks in Florida. It was a fantastic hotel and the staff couldnt have been nicer. We had a family room with 2 bedrooms which worked great with having 2 older boys. And 2 younger children. The Red Flam diner next door proved a huge hit for breakfast! The evening cookie in the room were a lovely touch and a big hit with the kids after a long day sightseeing! Highly recommend! .

Great location”

Number one factor is the great location amongst other hotels and close to Times Square and Fifth Avenue. The staff were also friendly and are able to arrange or hail a taxi. The bathroom was quite nice. As a bonus, chocolate chip cookies upon arrival and every night of my stay! Only issue is that the electric sockets in the room are a bit old and loose sometimes.

Exceptional”

Small, but quant hotel in the heart of times square with friendly service from all hotel staff. Great toiletry products and nice smell as soon as you get off the elevators. Good night time staff and security on the floors.

Nobody does it better!”

City Club has all anyone needs without charging more for a bunch of unnecessary faciliities. Location is perfect. Staff is unfailingly kind and efficient and rooms are ample and well equipped.

Overall a good stay”

Location is prime, walking distance to major tourist attractions. I was in New York for a meeting and looking forward to come back to city club hotel.

Fantastic location, great room, entrance looks like a walk in closet”

This was a great hotel stay, staff extra professional and friendly, room with a beautiful design, large bathroom with great toiletries and cookies delivered to the room every evening (given the sign "Do not disturb" isn't on the door). The entrance might be a bit underwhelming, it looks like a door to a walk in closet, and it belies the level of the rooms of the hotel overall. Very satisfied, a WARM recommendation.

Would definitely stay here again. ”

Staff was helpful and accommodating. Room size was very comfortable size by NY standards.