Agoda Hero Banner

Find Hotels in Shelter Island (NY), United States

6 vacation rentals and hotels available now

6 best hotels in Shelter Island (NY)

Star rating
Review score
Our top picks
Lowest price first
Nearest to
Best reviewed
Sunset Beach Hotel
Shelter Island,Shelter Island (NY) - View on map
Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
Shelter Island,Shelter Island (NY) - View on map
House on Chase Creek
Shelter Island,Shelter Island (NY) - View on map
West Neck Guesthouse
Shelter Island,Shelter Island (NY) - View on map
The Chequit
Shelter Island,Shelter Island (NY) - View on map
The Pridwin Hotel
Shelter Island,Shelter Island (NY) - View on map

Fast facts about Shelter Island (NY), United States

Accommodations6 properties
Popular hotelSunset Beach Hotel
Popular areaShelter Island
Nightly rates fromC$287
Today's Top Deals
10% OFF
Expires in 1 week!
Get an additional 10% discount on top of great deals in Melbourne
10% OFF
Expires in 1 week!
Valid on bookings made 18 Jun 2021 through 1 Jul 2021 for accommodation that shows the option to enter a coupon code on the booking form.
Search Properties
8% OFF
Expires in 2 days!
Get 8% off your accommodations in Maldives Islands now
8% OFF
Expires in 2 days!
Valid on bookings made 12 Jun 2021 through 25 Jun 2021 for accommodation that shows the option to enter a coupon code on the booking form.
Search Properties
5% OFF
Expires in 4 days!
Dreaming of the beach? Get 5% off in Cancun.
5% OFF
Expires in 4 days!
Valid on bookings made 21 Jun 2021 through 27 Jun 2021 for accommodation that shows the option to enter a coupon code on the booking form.
Search Properties

Just viewed by other Agoda travelers



More about Shelter Island (NY)

Agoda.com features accommodation options from all over town. From high end international chain hotels to family run guesthouses, demands of all travelers are met. Whether traveling for business or leisure, Shelter Island (NY) is an outstanding city to visit with over 11 hotels to choose from. Many areas, each with a distinctive atmosphere, are just waiting to be discovered across the city. Shelter Island (NY) has many attractions to explore with its fascinating past, intriguing present and exciting future. There are so many things to do, you may want to stay an extra week or so to experience them all. Agoda.com offers professional reviews and ratings of hotels in Shelter Island (NY) so you can enjoy the perfect stay.


null