disapointing”

The carpet in the room was dirty. The alley outside the room smelled terrible. Location is ok.

Typical Holiday Inn at Edinburgh ”

Room size is bigger than average UK hotel, since the location is not near downtown. It is a typical Holiday Inn style, however there is laundry room as in USA. The reception staff is really helpful and recommended a nice laundromat with reasonable prices. I recommend the hotel because of the professional and useful services.

Beautiful views, wonderful hotel”

Really nice hotel for the price. Most amenities we’ve seen in a while, plus the views are breathtaking. We had a car, so we easily drove into the city in about 10 minutes. There’s also a grocery store right across the street. WiFi and parking were included. Breakfast was not, but they offered a good deal for guests.

Nice hotel, great staffs”

The thing i like most is the staff and the room. The price was a bit pricey as we booked on the last minute for year end stay (fair enough). Location is about 30-40 mins walking to city but still acceptable to walk, and not expensive by uber.

Great Hotel”

Spacious room and very clean. Staff is pleasant and polite.

Exceptional”

big room with nice view , bed comfort. staff nice .

Good”

Good

Excellent room space for 4 adults per room”

Stay was comfortable except the noise the water system created when water was turned on from other toilet (water hammer). Can be uncomfortable. Check-In counter lady needs to be more polite when observing check-in clients standing in front of the counter instead of talking to his colleague on a non importance personal thing. At least address me to wait for a while. Not even a blink even though i said "good afternoon".

Rod Thornton”

Having stayed at other hotels of the same grade, this one was a better run unit. he only problem I had, was the TV in the bar lounge was faulty for 2 days, so no pint and no football on TV to watch.

Value for money”

Good stay”

The stay was good, the bed was big, breakfast is good too, free carparking

Comfortable but not near to town. ”

Fine to us, initially v not used to location as we need to travel about 20 mins by bus to town. No Internet connection.

Cozy, friendly staff”

Clean room, friendly staff, ok location Quite good option since it's during the Open week, overall happy with the hotel.

staffs at the front desk are nice”

No safety box and refrigerator but the room is nice. Around 15min to the waverley station by bus.

easy access and affordable”

Good location for city centre”

Fairly average 3+ star hotel well situated near main route to city centre and out of town.

Good service and very clean.”

holiday inn edinburgh city west is located in the comfortable area that you can easily get the bus into city certre of edinburgh. besides it is near the big superstore that you can find something to eat whenever you want. due to its location that is a little bit up on the hill, you can view the beautiful city from the window in your room. the room that i stayed is very clean and well functioned. check in and out services do not take a long time. everything is good. i loved it.

Great hotel”

great hotel. friendly reception staff. friendly restaurant waiters and waiteress. good menu,good tasty food. clean room,comfortable bed,nice linen. great location near bus route into the city centre. good price for time of year. recommend the hotel

Nice and big hotel”

Hotel is located just outside the city, and opposite a large supermarket. It offers free parking for guests and there is no problem finding an available lot. There is a direct bus to the city from a bus stop just outside the hotel, hence it's convenient. Room is very clean and spacious and so is the toilet. We had a view of the city from our room and it was magnificent. Hotel staff are friendly and helpful. There are quite many facilities/amenities available including a restaurant but we did not use those so we can't comment.

Truly excellent value for money”

given what we paid for this hotel, i was astonished that it was so good. the rooms were a decent size, friendly and flexible reception, easy parking. really very pleasantly surprised. we had booked it purely on price and proximity to the airport and so expected much, much less. all in all, very positively and pleasantly surprised.