Great location and value for money”

Friendly staff, excellent location and comfortable beds. Above all the location is great, with Times Square being literally around the corner, great and easy access to Subway stations (E line serving the Airport route to Jamaica Center, N, R, W and Q lines that follow broadway and combine with Brooklyn and Queens, as well as the 1 line that takes you downtown to WTC and the Staten Island ferry) The single room is small, so if you only have a carry on luggage, no problem. If you have more than one big suitcase, you should consider a bigger room. The aircon is very noisy when switched on, so only switch it on when the room needs to be cooled down a bit. Shower is comfortable, although it only switches on and off, without the option of adjusting the force/amount of water coming out. The hotel may seem a bit old, but it is a comfortable stay and it's good for you to sleep in, so don't spend so much time in your room, go enjoy the Big Apple! Note: this hotel often does promotions on Agoda, so you can get some pretty sweet deals. I paid under $300 for a 4 nights stay, which is an absolutely insane deal for a New York hotel with that kind of location, with your own bathroom.

As always.,Times Square best bargain.”

The Mayfair is my go to hotel on my bi - annual trips to New York City. I go to see theatre, and the hotel on 49th St is perfectly located. The single rooms are tiny with strange wallpaper, but who cares. They are clean, and the bed is comfortable. In the last couple of years, hotels have invented a "resort tax." in order to advertise a cheap room rate, and then hit you for up to and extra $80. a night for nothing. The Mayfair's "tax" at this writing is only $7.00 a night. I can live with that.

Excellent value, great staff, clean room”

Staff was super friendly & helpful, room was clean, bed comfortable, location was wonderful. Had a business dinner at the restaurant & again, staff & service was great, food delicious. If you want modern & sleek with million dollar views, this isn’t the hotel for you. If you want a clean, friendly place to explore New York from, I would definitely recommend it. I’d stay here again.

Great Value for NYC”

So... accommodations are a nightmare in NYC. Keep in mind that everything is relative. The Mayfair offers a great location- not so much because of proximity to Times Square but more due to proximity to mid-town in general (I understand the urge to avoid Time's Square)- Hell's Kitchen, Central Park, Empire State, Rockefeller Center, St. Patricks, all easily accessible. The staff were friendly, bathrooms surprisingly nice, and relative to other accommodations in NYC, Mayfair is affordable. Its a bit dated and the AC could be worked on but, all in all, it was a reasonable pick.

Hotel on broadway”

I like stay at mayfair new york because: location near broadway,shopping mall,restaurant, staff very nice, room perfect for me.

Great stay”

Went for a vacation with my husband from March 29-April 6,2019.....enjoyed our stay at this hotel,it’s only 3 minutes walk to times square...subway close by...all staff are very friendly and easy to deal with...arrived early like around 11 am and Joe the manager,allowed us to check in early free of charge...rooms are very clean specially the bathroom...kinda hesitant to book at first because of some reviews but great that i still booked it ...Happy and satisfied. I would highly recommend this hotel....worth the price 👍

Night In NYC”

Great little hotel. Room was kind of small, but this is New York City. You can't beat the location for the price. Chances are you will only be sleeping in your room anyway. It was plenty sufficient for our needs.

Small room, but great for solo traveller”

I arrived and checked into a very small single room. It was fine. I had one large piece of luggage and a smaller one as well. There wasn't a lot of space but it all fit alright. A little bit difficult to open the larger one in the room but I managed to fully open it in the doorway. The elevator is a bit odd. If you get in with someone going to a different level, it stops at the higher level first. Otherwise, the location is perfect. Walking distance to everything. I came for the Broadway shows and they were all very close by. The tkts booth in time square was close enough to buy all the tickets I wanted when I woke up and then come back to rest as well. I would highly recommend the Mayfair for solo travellers, I'm not sure if there's enough space in the rooms for a couple or larger group.

Great location”

Great location time square and Broadway are only steps away plus the hop on buses stop just around the corner. Staff were friendly and help full. The down side is the decor is dated and a bit grubby and could do with some maintenance. Also the AC was so loud you had to turn it off at night as you wouldn't be able to sleep with it on. But over all I would say a good place to stay to experience New York.

Perfect location! Average hotel but value for money! ”

Mayfair Hotel is an older hotel but is decent enough that you can ignore that. Room was small but had its own bathroom which was hard to find in Manhattan budget hotels. Staff is very helpful and nice from the moment we checked in till we checked out. We were looking for a hotel at the “center of it all” in NYC that would not break the bank and this is just perfect. However, heating is centralized and the room was relatively cold still. Mind you, it was freezing in NYC during our stay too so pretty sure their boilers were working extra hard. So if you are not looking for frills and just looking for something that is simple and works for your basic needs then this is the hotel for you. I would definitely stay here again if I were to go back to NYC. The price cannot be beat!

Location, location, location”

Near Time Square, subway station and convenience store, this quaint hotel has a lot going for it. The lobby is small, but well appointed. The room, bed and bathroom are small, but quiet. It was perfect for a single occupant and would be fine for an intimate couple. The room and hotel are showing it's age though reasonably clean. The bathroom is well appointed and uses it's space well. The room has a safe, iron & board and hair dryer. The bathroom fan was not working in my room. This place has 7 floors of rooms and I had one of the few rooms with a view on the 7th floor. The elevator is ridiculously small. Though it's rated for 1800 lbs, it's comfotable for 1-2 persons, less so with 3 and at 4 it becomes a clown car. The staff are friendly and helpful. There is an Italian restaurant adjoining the hotel (I didn't check it out) and a well stocked convenience store on the corner (I got a late night snack there). The subway station for the C-E trains, 1 block away.

Good”

The hotel charged me extra for "room taxes". I thought this had already been included in my prepayment. After staying there, I later moved into another nearby hotel in New York (previously booked thru another website) for similar number of days and price. This new hotel did not charged any extra "room taxes" as they were already included in my prepayment.

Perfect location, great value for money, clean. Exactly what you need in the heart of NYC..”

If you like exploring and spending most of your time outdoors whilst visiting a city this little hotel is perfect for you. If you like to have lots of space, spa and modern decor, stay elsewhere. After lots of mixed reviews I was worried about staying at this hotel but just returned from a 5 night trip and I am still buzzing. The hotel was great, clean, friendly staff and amazing location. For a bargain price, I would definitely recommend and stay again. Thanks guys!

Good location ”

Very convenient and near to the metro, by walking 5 min to time square, Many restaurant around there.

Very unique hotel”

If you are on a tight budget, want to stay in the heart of the Theater District and want just a room w/o the frills this is the perfect hotel for you. The bed was cozy enough but the room was very small. The shower had very low water pressure but we cured that by getting the debris out of the shower head. We did enjoy our stay. The staff was very nice and happy to give us any information we were looking for. Its a short walk to Times Square and Central Park. And of course, if you are here for a Broadway show, they are on your block or just around the corner. We never felt unsafe in this area and we were coming in late. Be prepared to scratch your head at their choice to match the wall paper, headboard, lamp shade, pillow case and curtains all with the same design. I believe Al Jolson thought the same thing.

Excellent Location!”

Walking distance to Times Square, Blue Line Subway, Supermarket, many Broadway Theaters and gift shops. Room is decent and value-for-money.

Worth every bucks I spend”

Tbh, before I came here, I’ve been reading reviews on the hotel and many of them were quiet negative. What I experienced on the first day of my arrival, was totally different from the review I’ve read. The staffs were nice and friendly and very helpful. The room was tiny, but it was in a perfect size, since it was only me staying there and it was clean. The location is absolutely perfect and safe, 2 blocks from timesquare and many attractions, they are all within a walking distance. Totally recommended this hotel for anyone. :)

Traveler”

Clean, cozy room for single traveler, tiny though. Given the price of $80 at midtown Manhattan near Time Square, it is unbeatable.

Location Great! ”

Of course price was high, but the cheapest at the time. Still great hotel.

unbeatable price and location”

forget about the negative reviews! if you need a comfortable bed, very clean restroom and a place where the middle of the action is... this is where you want to stay. small rooms but hey! this is manhattan! subway is few steps away! time square is 5 mins walk! nothing can go wrong! so what if its an old dated hotel! you are there not to stay in the hotel all day! be wise! save your money and stay here! highly recommended!